Reflections on Kay Wilson's messianic past, her refusal to admit her documented missionary associations, and what this refusal might say about her current beliefs and attitude.
The most troublesome aspect of this whole mess is that mainstream "hasbara" organisations gave Wilson an entry pass into the world of Israeli advocacy without ever properly addressing these troubling issues with her, nor has Wilson given any indication that she engaged in proper Torah repentance. On the contrary. She continues to deny the allegations. and yet I have never heard of her suing any of these messianic organizations for tarring her name in print. The Jewish people have a right to know the truth.
MP3 File
My unabashed, unapologetic reflections on Judaism's authentic approach to the physical and spiritual dangers facing the Jewish people today, both in the modern state of Israel and in the diaspora.
Monday, September 19, 2016
Sunday, September 18, 2016
"Confrontation" Revisited: Rav Soloveitchik's Classic Treatise
In these trying times when ignorant, unlearned, and unprincipled Jewish "leaders" align with evangelical missionaries for their purported support of Israel, it behooves decent Jews to revisit Rav Soloveitchik's classic works on interfaith dialogue. What we are saying today reflects the vacuum of Jewish leadership of our times. Not only are those engaged in these dangerous relationships violating the most basic aspects of the Rav's position, but most of them are frighteningly ignorant (and largely disinterested) of the issues involved. Dark times indeed.
Labels:
"Confrontation"
,
evangelical
,
Halacha
,
interfaith diaogue
,
missionaries
,
Rav Soloveitchik
,
Torah
Thursday, August 11, 2016
LAVI Exposed
Why is LAVI, a Jewish "indigenous rights" movement, a dangerous organization?
- Among other things, LAVI is involved in defending Israel based upon our supposed Jewish indigenous rights (premised on bad history and science, and irrelevant to the thinking person) and see this as a viable means of defending our Jewish connection to Israel. As such, LAVI de-emphasizes the Divine claim, which represents our only true claim to the land. For further information on the foolishness of Jewish indigenous rights activists, check out the following articles where I elaborate on this issue: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/columns/fuchs-focus/263683/2016/03/03/ http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/columns/fuchs-focus/we-are-still-not-indigenous-a-counter-response/2016/03/28/
- Unlike other pro-Israel groups which seek to deny indigenous status to Arabs in Israel based upon their selective interpretation of the term, LAVI grants this identity to Arabs and based upon this, see them as "partners" for peace. It matters little for the G-d-fearing individual, since the Torah gives Am Yisrael the entire land, and when the halachic criteria of Jewish control of the land is met, neither Arabs nor any gentiles have the right to reside in the land, if they don't meet the halachic criteria for "resident strangers". In any event, LAVI is in actuality a peace movement and they endanger the Jewish people with foolish ventures. For more on this aspect of LAVI and similiar organizations, check out the following article: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/columns/fuchs-focus/the-new-indigenous-right-hardline-or-soft-boiled/2016/05/22/
- LAVI embraces the vile and violent black supremacist movement "Black Lives Matter", whose members include those with blood on their hands, and many more who support and celebrate such actions. BLM terrorists are responsible for murdering innocent cops in America (black and white) and ordinary citizens. They desire a race war and in this regard they are merely a mirror image of the KKK but with more credibility among the left. See: http://thejudeanhammer.blogspot.co.il/2016/08/ignorance-begets-wickedness.html
- LAVI foments discord between Jews by presenting a false skewed image of romanticized non-white "indigenous Jewry" and a colonized westernized Ashkenazic Jewry which needs to "de-colonize" and "reclaim" it's identity. Judaism is comprised of many peoples and neither color, language, or region define us. The Torah alone is our standard. If Ashkenazic Jewry is no more authentic than Sephardic Jewry, neither is it less so.
This is just the tip of the proverbial iceberg. More to come.
Wednesday, August 10, 2016
Ignorance Begets Wickedness
Evidently, it
wasn’t enough that many Jewish activists and organizations, largely run by
religious Jews, falsely create a shared identify with the many primitive
peoples of the world (past and present) who have nothing in common with Jews.
And yet, in the interest of pandering to liberal multicultural hasbara types,
they’ve created nonsensical associations with people whose ideas are actively
contrary to our most sacred beliefs. My views
on this were expressed in previous articles.
The logical
extension of this illogical thought process led to other problems. After
exposing this disturbing trend of indigenous fixation, I was compelled to
revisit the issue to expose the “new peace movements” which many of these same people
are creating, based upon the foolish notion that our supposed shared indigenous
status with Arabs (as they would have it) can bring about peace. I addressed
this problem in yet another article,
reflecting on the sentiments of one particular “rightist” activist who saw fit
to express a theoretical empathy with the Arab’s “Nakba.”
And yet it
continues, because unrestrained foolishness and the absence of wisdom begets
wickedness. If there weren’t enough reasons to oppose indigenous rights
activists for Israel who eschew or de-emphasize our Divine claim to Eretz
Yisroel, in lieu of baseless, pseudo-scientific, irrelevant claims of
purported indigeneity, we now have one more. In yet another example of clichéd
foolishness running amuck, the Jewish indigenous rights organization LAVI is
now calling for Jews to support the racist “Black Lives Matter” movement.
All sane jaws
should drop. This would naturally preclude those liberal jaws who are more
bothered by an “All Lives Matter” hashtag than a growing black supremacist
organization whose acceptability among blacks and liberals is far more
mainstream that the KKK ever was. A violent organization with the blood of countless
innocent police officers (black and white) and ordinary citizens, staining
their hands. An organization headed by racist thugs who would spill blood
throughout America on the altar of their race war.
LAVI exposed
themselves with this latest “Black Lives Matter” gimmick to pander to young
Jewish liberals. With any luck, sensible Jews who may have supported them
previously will perhaps give pause and reconsider. Any organization that
supports such a group or calls for Jews to understand them is beyond the pale. The
BLM movement is the mirror image of the Ku Klux Klan, and the lives of the
thugs who join such a movement are as worthless as those who would join any group
which terrorizes another based upon color. The following post is from LAVI’s
Facebook page. My commentary follows each paragraph or two in order to
address every dangerous sentiment.
LAVI: The Jewish establishment's reaction
to The
Movement for Black Lives platform is embarrassing but not
surprising. It focuses on what the platform says about Israel rather than
addressing the policy ideas developed by a broad coalition of Black leaders to
attain justice for their people within the United States. The reactions coming
out of the Jewish establishment also come across as completely ignorant and
insensitive to the fact that there actually does exist a discriminatory system
in the US that disenfranchises people of color through formal institutions and
informal group practices (Jews have been both the victims of and beneficiaries
of white privilege).
The Judean Hammer: What Jewish establishment are they
referring to? The mainstream liberal Jewish establishment(s) which reflects the
views of too many American Jews is largely sympathetic in theory at least to
the actions of these thugs and other groups such as the New Black Panther
Movement. In this case, the people from LAVI are surely referring to another
Jewish Establishment. That is, any group that retains what many such activists
deem a white, colonized “ashkenazic” identity which rejects their multicultural
worldview. And this exposes what is the most perverse notion of LAVI’s doctrine.
Their oft repeated hostility towards anything deemed ashkenazic, which they see
as a rejection of Jewish identity. (Needless to belabor the point, since they
say as much in the following paragraphs.)
As far as discriminatory systems in America,
what are they talking about? What year is this, 1947, or even 1967? There is no
legal discrimination in the United States. If anything, the liberal system and
continued chaos of Obama’s America created a system of discrimination which
supports and encourages the violence of racist groups like Black Lives Matter, of
brutal cop-killers and those who would kill whites on the altar of black
supremacy.
LAVI: Jewish groups on the left also appear to
miss an important opportunity to find the appropriate place for our people
within the struggles of other oppressed groups. They prefer to participate as
privileged white Americans of the Mosaic persuasion rather than as another
minority group struggling to overcome injustices actually caused by the same
system currently oppressing Blacks (Jewish Voices for Peace going so far as to
refer to its own Ashkenazi leadership as "white supremacy inside of
JVP").
Most Jews in the US fail to appreciate the fact that
Jewish white-passing largely exists at the expense of the Jewish
ethnic/cultural distinctions that not so long ago identified us as
"non-white" (even in America). As a result of past traumas, the
betrayal of our own culture and the colonization of Jewish identity (the
relationship between the three should be obvious), Jews can often pass for
white but we must remain conscious of the price our people have paid and
continue to pay for this "privilege" (and another group not even
having the option of paying this price does not negate the damage that this
price has caused our people.
The Judean Hammer: More
race-baiting from LAVI. What proof do they have to generalize about the driving
efforts of liberal Jews? The words of an extreme left-wing self-hating Jewish
organization who perversely refer to their own misguided leadership as
exhibiting white supremacy?
LAVI: The illusion of Jewish "whiteness"
can only exist when one contextualizes Jewish identity in the US according to
the paradigm of another people's experiences and challenges (Jews can be
considered "white" within the context of the injustices many people
of color experience due to being "not white" but this has little to
do with our own understanding of our people's unique identity/history/challenges/collective
experience). And the fact that Jews have had to change our names, shrink our
noses, straighten our hair and betray our own culture and values in order to
achieve a "white privilege" defined by what others are denied is
telling enough. We should also be cautious not to define our people's situation
in America according to a temporary - and potentially fleeting - reality. In many
Diasporas over the centuries, periods where Jews enjoyed the illusions of
privilege and belonging were often followed up by harsh - and in some cases
catastrophic - wake-up calls.
The Judean Hammer: LAVI
sounds like a bad cliché of from the late 60’s. Their infantile generalizations
are laden with expressions parroting standard liberal notions of guilt. The
fact that many Jews may have tried to alter or conceal heritage, religion, or
identity, does not mean that we should create a new false identity to cater to
liberal multiculturalism. Jew haters will never support Jewish interests, and the attempt
to redefine Judaism to obtain support is reprehensible.
LAVI: Our own unique experiences, hardships and
traumas should not desensitize us to the pain or struggles of others. We should
obviously demonstrate solidarity with and seek justice for those facing very
real injustices today. But we should do so not as representatives of white
America but as another minority group with different challenges and struggles unique
to our own experience.
#DecolonizeJewishIdentity #BlackLivesMatter #BrownLivesMatter#SemiticLivesMatter #NewGenerationNewConversation
#DecolonizeJewishIdentity #BlackLivesMatter #BrownLivesMatter#SemiticLivesMatter #NewGenerationNewConversation
The Judean Hammer: We Jews should do what all self-respecting
people do, and what the great Rabbi Meir Kahane noted early on in his activist
career. We need to attend to our own house first. And to the extent that there
is room to support other just causes, it must always be within the framework of
supporting those causes the Torah would deem just.
As such, all decent Jews
should unequivocally condemn and oppose the ideology, actions, and the existence
of racist groups such as “Black Lives Matter”, as they would towards any group
such as the KKK. The ranks of Black Lives Matter all hate Jews (even liberal
ones!) and Israel just as their forebears did.
This was recently illustrated when members of the BLM movement came to
Israel to support the Arabs and show their Jew-hatred.
BLM’s cause is patently unjust,
and it is fueled by the poisonous motives of black race baiters and racist liberals
to perpetuate hatred and discontent. As Jews, we should support the police who
are ambushed and preyed upon by these racist terrorists in the streets of
America, and who remain the lone defense against a race war perpetuated against
the rest of America.
I hold no sympathy with
bigots of any color, and I am aware of American history. America is not the
racist country Obama would have it. Of course racism exists in the hearts of
too many diseased people, both black and white. But long before the creation of
BLM, statistics proved that black on white violence was far greater than that
of white on black, as it has been for some time in America. And let us not venture
into the issue of the epidemic of black on black violence, which remains the
real threat to blacks.
Black lives matter not at
all to the thugs who form the rank and file of Black Lives Matter. These racist
thugs care nothing at all for the fractured black family, and the rampant
violence within their community that eats up black society. If they did, they
would support such righteous people as Colonel Allen West, Sheriff Clarke, Ben
Carson, and the noted intellectual Thomas Sowell who exemplify the best of
mankind and are best equipped to help blacks in America with their leadership
and knowledge.
But they don’t. They choose the Sharpton’s, the Jackson’s, the Farrakhan’s
and the Obama’s. And they overwhelmingly support black hate groups like BLM.
And the fact that LAVI would align with such a vile organization which cares
nothing for people, be they black or white, is terrifying and tragic. And it
shrieks of ignorance.
LAVI has nothing of
importance to say to Jews or gentiles, not on matters of Judaism and not on
matter of race. They merely perpetuate another form of racism. Liberal
multicultural racism which celebrates everything ethnic and demonizes anything
with a “white hue” or appears to them as indicative of white colonialism. LAVI
often expresses sentiments which would earn them the term racism if the term,
black, Sephardic, Asian, etc. was replaced with white. Smart Jews would do well
to stay away from such organizations. From a Torah perspective, any man is
equal to another provided he retains his Divine image and uses his reason.
Evidently, the leadership of LAVI see more kinship with BLM bigots who
ambush and gun down cops in the streets, or their mainstream supporters who applaud the thugs who do.
It is a chillul Hashem to
allow such grotesque views masquerading as “Jewish” to go unopposed. America is
in the middle of a domestic war with Islam run amuck and black racist groups
terrorizing the populace. A proper Jewish perspective should be heard. The BLM movement
should be destroyed along with the thugs of the New Black Panther Movement, the
same for any group that terrorizes people based upon color, ethnicity, or
religion.
I am sick of LAVI’s
polarizing message trying to drive a wedge between Jews. The Torah has no
interest in race. Man is judged by his actions. I am sick of LAVI’s obsession
with color. Color is as relevant as one’s shoe size or their choice in movies. Black,
white, who gives a damn? Certainly not the rational, thinking Jew.
#divinerightsnotindigenousrights
#torahrising
#neitherblacknorwhitebutjewish
Labels:
BLM Movement
,
indigenous rights
,
LAVI
,
liberals
Wednesday, July 27, 2016
Monsters Exist: Judaism’s Cognizance of Evil
“To most of us nothing is so invisible as
an unpleasant truth. Though it is
held before our eyes, pushed under our noses, rammed down our throats-we know
it not.”-Eric Hoffer, “The
Passionate State of Mind, and Other Aphorisms (1955)
“The
soul that has conceived one wickedness, can nurse no good thereafter.”-Sophocles
The Moral Lies We Tell
Torah is truth personified. Yet some truths cannot be
said. We recognize that lying is odious. Yet some lies are permitted, such as
the lies we tell to shield people from embarrassment or to protect the
innocent. When we occasionally lie to our children to insulate them from things
that no child should know about, we do so with a clear conscience. Lies of
omission, lies of calculation. All for the good of the child.
To assuage their fears when they are very young, we assure
them that there are no such things as childhood monsters with horns, fur, and
teeth. In time, we teach them that while there are indeed wild creatures in
this world with teeth and hearty appetites, civilized societies don’t have
predatory animals roaming about. But what about the true monsters in this
world, the human monsters who exist? How do we broach these topics?
We don’t. We avoid the question of those products of
nature and nurture who commit acts as terrifying as any imaginary construct. The
developing child approaches us with their ever expanding brains and the
consequential concerns. We counter their inquiries. They bring it to us. No
normal rational parent introduces these concepts.
Children first have a notion of robbers, and this
often becomes the first anxiety relating to the real world. The killers, the
rapists, the human predators, these are extensions of the first fear. The man
who enters the home. The man who creeps about in the night while we sleep. When
this first fear is articulated, we evade difficult questions with comforting
solutions, to assure them of their safety, and help them mature into functional
people, without the handicap of excessive anxiety. We pray to G-d that they will
never meet such people, neither in childhood nor their adult lives. We tell them
lies. We protect them as best we can. But life can be ugly.
Monsters in Our Midst
“You gave me a present and now I am returning it
to you.”-Hallel’s mother Rena
Ariel; at her murdered daughter’s funeral
A teenage girl’s bedroom should be the safest place in
the world for her, a haven of privacy and seclusion. And in the normal world,
it usually is. But not in Kiryat Arba, where the Jewish populace is
surrounded by Arab barbarians. Home may be a man’s castle in his mind, but
unguarded castles are easily stormed. Even within the illusion of gated
communities, and electronic fences, and security patrols, these measures are
only as good as the people maintaining them.
And when the mythology of security is shattered it is
devastating. An insane image, impossible to fathom: a child’s bedroom drenched
in her own blood. Portrait of Hallel
Yaffa Ariel’s bedroom on June 30, 2016, courtesy of a
17-year-old Arab monster named Muhammad Tarayrah, who climbed through her bedroom window and stabbed her to
death as she slept.
May G-d avenge Hallel’s blood. And may
Hashem teach the Arabs of Kiryat Arba, the environs, and of Greater Israel the
justice of the ancient city of Shchem.
Outside the realm of hasbara fantasy, most Israelis are
unarmed and vulnerable, and although many people oppose the draconian laws
which permit only the elite to obtain a legal weapon to protect themselves,
many are not even bothered. In such a society, the terminally enlightened concern
themselves with “restraint,” the rights of murderers, and perpetuating the
system of apprehending terrorists. Such a society breeds weakness, because it
denies the common man the most basic right of all, the right to live. The kind
of society where the worst of humankind terrorize the innocent.
Whether maimed or murdered, or damned to witness the
former, when people encounter human monsters their lives are ruined. In the
same way that no one who survived the Holocaust can truly ever be “normal,” how
can one who saw his parents gunned down or stabbed to death or hacked to bits, ever
know normalcy? Can a society forced to endure endless Arab atrocities even appreciate
the concept of normalcy?
There is no dearth of monsters in Israel. Man-beasts
who resemble man but act less human than carnivores. Men who cast away their humanity
and choose the evil. Arabs nursed on ideations of suicide/homicide martyrdom
and are given every opportunity to actualize their madness. Arabs who stab
babies in cribs and detonate themselves in the marketplace to attain said “martyrdom”
and the depraved fantasies of Islam’s sexual pathology. Those Arab
“passion-plays”, obscene Arabs theater featuring school children who reenact
the slaughter of Jews. And Arabs who stab teenage girls in their bedrooms.
And still the left and clueless governments continue
to perpetuate the myth of good Arabs. Of reasonable Arabs. Of Arabs who want to
live in peace with Jews. These same politicians have the nerve to attend Jewish
funerals and pay shiva calls. They speak of protecting Jews and yet Jews
are sitting ducks in Israel. On many roads, Jews are targets for Arab snipers
or cinder blocks. Or firebombs to burn his wife and children to death or
destroy a little girl’s face. Even crossing the street in Jerusalem or buying
milk can become an ordeal, should the Arab knife frenzy return, or the Arabs
rediscover their predilection for crushing Jews with automobiles.
The government never calls for vengeance. Social media
outlets for military and government speak of the murdered “of blessed memory”, the
tamest of words suggesting that a murdered Jew slipped away in the night from
old age. “May G-d avenge her blood” is considered the refrain of extremists. Netanyahu
blasts Abbas and the “PA” for incitement. If as the sages of old taught us, the
wise man is one who foresees the future, then the fool pokes out his own eyes
and sees nothing. What on G-d’s earth did Bibi think he would accomplish?
Compel Abbas to repent?
Thank G-d the latest Arab terror attack in Jerusalem
was thwarted. But in Israel, the positive is laced with negative. Averted
bloodshed doesn’t preclude the possibility of future bloodshed. On the
contrary. Israel’s ethic of “do-the-least harm was on display. The terrorist
was apprehended rather than having his head blown off. He will sit for a time,
and as sure as the day is long, he will be part of a future prisoner release, as
one with ‘no blood on his hands’. And when he is released, he will attempt to
rectify his failure.
In Israel, the uncompromising warrior is often treated
like a fiend, or a lawless vigilante. A soldier such as Elor Azaria who kills an Arab terrorist is a hero, and
any "Jewish" government that punishes such a warrior is
reprehensible. I don't care if the creature was trussed up like a Thanksgiving
Turkey. Or whether or not the ghoul had an explosive. A bullet to the head is
the Jewish response. You can bet your last shekel that King David would have
agreed. The witch-hunt against Azaria shrieks of Jewish degradation. Such actions
are the antidote to Jewish funerals.
The
double standard is jarring. The Left gets away with incitement to murder.
Academics, journalists, activists, etc. They can say anything on twitter,
Facebook or in a prominent paper. Military men can compare Israeli society to
the society that birthed the disease of Nazism. Without any consequence. All
during a “right-wing” government. Several months ago, the morally defective
leftist editor of Walla News Roy Baharir Perl called for Arab terrorists
to attack a “right-wing” Jewish concert. While this incitement was spread all
over social media, our government tortured and imprisoned innocent Jews, on a
witch-hunt to seek out supposed "Jewish terrorists". If Perl was a
right-winger, he would have been hanging upside down within the hour while Shabak
agents pummeled him.
A
government who refuses to protect the Nation and imprisons those who do, sends a
message that 1) Jewish lives aren’t valued. 2) Jewish deaths are acceptable if
the threshold of “acceptable losses” doesn’t remarkably change the status quo. 3)
that Rabin’s perverse notion of “karbanot” for an impossible peace is pragmatic.
A government and a society which spurns the gift of Jewish strength and holds
its fire has blood on its hands. Jewish history will recall these sins born of
weakness and self-loathing, whose consequences destroy lives and those of the
survivors. Orphans and widows and parents who bury their young. Of sons and
daughters who shriek “Abba”, as their beloved father is interred into the
earth. Of a mother who one day drove her girl to dance class, and the next day
spills tears stands over her murdered corpse.
Given
Israel’s torturous form of government where a hodgepodge of groups usually
forms a coalition, the question remains: How precisely to coordinate and
implement the proper framework for genuine change? There are no easy answers,
since yesterday’s best tactics are not necessarily feasible and today's are
useless. We need to use the best resources of our age. However, short of
an undeserved miracle, nothing short of mass civil disobedience will make a
dent in the government's armor. When society wakes up and takes to the streets in
unprecedented numbers, we will see the possibility for change. Articles and
videos will not bring about change, no matter how provocative, powerful, or
reasoned. They may cause people to think. They may inspire people, but nothing
short of authentic societal grassroots effort on the ground, can rehabilitate
our collective Jewish soul.
The
pernicious effect of havlaga can only be cleansed with Jewish strength
and unrelenting power. There is no place on earth for mercy with the Arabs.
Truly, they are the Am Lak-a nation that laps Jewish blood. The company
of man-eating lions is preferable. When Arabs kill Jews it is perverse to
celebrate our humanity with assurances that “we love while they hate”. Of
course we are not like them. And that is precisely why the Torah demands that
we destroy the wicked. The failure to do so, results in OUR slaughter. It is
time to scream and demand that our government deals with the Arabs once and for
all, before the next round of Jewish funerals.
Those
terrible funerals. Those horrifying images of parents clinging and shrieking
over the small inanimate bodies of their children all dressed in shrouds, awaiting
the final journey. I prefer the funerals of my enemies. And every Arab funeral
where the blood-crazed jinn celebrate their shahid is a G-d given
opportunity to bomb them to smithereens. Whole villages of Arab terror can be obliterated
this way.
When
Moshiach arrives, he will be pressed to
identify Amalek. I am convinced that this most noble of men (may we see the
redemption in our times) will open his eyes wide with puzzlement: “Are you serious”, he will say? “They are all around you!”
“Pour
out YOUR wrath against the nations, who know YOU not.” During the joy of the
Passover seder, we call for vengeance against the evil nations. Some
distorted modern commentaries try to minimize the significance of this powerful
refrain in the Haggadah. It is significant and provocative. Unabashed
and unapologetic. The wicked deserve punishment, and unlike petty revenge
against a fellow Jew which is forbidden, this is something we long to see.
Jewish outrage as a counter to apathy and indifference. Strength and dignity to
repair the degradation, and self-respect for Torah and Halacha, rather than a
systematic attempt to explain away halachic obligations. With such a mindset,
we can finally deal with the Arabs.
We
need more of the teachings of torat Moshe Rabbeinu, and less of the arrogance
of Moshe Dayan. More of the glory of King David and less of David Ben Gurion’s
Ghandi-esque havlaga. And truth be told, we need more of Shimon and Levi whose
righteous zeal for their sister brought the city of Shchem to its knees. And lastly,
we need more of Shimshon Hagibor, who terrified and terrorized the Philistine enemy.
Labels:
Amalek
,
Arabs
,
Benjamin Netanyahu
,
Halacha
,
Hallel Yaffa Ariel
,
havlaga
,
leftists
,
Moshe Rabbeinu
,
Moshiach
,
Shimshon
,
Torah
Wednesday, July 20, 2016
Rabbi Haskel Lookstien's Terrible Decision (video)
Integrity, where art thou? |
Shameful and weak.
Download File
Tuesday, July 12, 2016
The Jewish People: Zero Commonality With Indians
Contrary to the ill-informed claims of self-appointed "hasbara" indigenous rights activists, "native-Americans" have little (if any) commonality with Jews. The analogy is ridiculous, and only one devoid of knowledge of Jewish history and Torah would ever make the comparison.
There is a reason "Indian rights" activists align with Arabs and their war with Israel. As angry malcontents with no future and no reasonable demands, they have an interest in disseminating myth as history and living the fantasy of a revolution that will never happen. And they have embraced antisemitism for self-interest:
There is a reason "Indian rights" activists align with Arabs and their war with Israel. As angry malcontents with no future and no reasonable demands, they have an interest in disseminating myth as history and living the fantasy of a revolution that will never happen. And they have embraced antisemitism for self-interest:
- As Jews we have a legacy and a mandate of bringing the knowledge of the One true G-d to the world. Indians were animistic pagans.
- Jewish law is predicated on the sanctity of human life. Biblical wars (and halachic wars were necessarily brutal) offered the enemy an opportunity to repent. They had a limited window to do so and to extricate themselves from the fate of their people. Native Americans were masters of collective mass slaughter, torture, rape, all sorts of depredations, physical, sexual assault, etc. A code of barbarism and savagery.
- Indians fled their origins in Siberia to find a new place to live- out of necessity. G-d GAVE us our land. And Jews have always yearned for the one place sacred to us, Eretz Yisrael.
- Jewish tribes were mandated to maintain unity and brotherhood, despite the unfortunate reality of factionalism that existed throughout the history of the monarchies. Indians were defined by their brutal violence towards each other long before any European came to the land.
- Judaism appreciates nature as the creation of G-d. Indians venerated and worshiped nature. And contrary to the mythos of the ecological native, many tribes were destructive to nature. Judaism has a balance where man must conserve the world but still retain dominion over it.
- Indian society was cruel by any standard, and the violence they often meted out towards the ill and infirm was shocking. Judaism repudiates the cruel personality.
- Judaism is intellectual. Our halachic system is based on logic. Indians were creatures of impulse, even if it was contrary to their best interests.
- Judaism has never shied from documenting our less than stellar moments in history. The Torah and Talmud often record events that portray as us sinful, ungrateful, and generally belligerent to Hashem. Truth is never sanitized. Indian history is defined by pseudo-history and her advocates all have one narrative. White raping exploitative Europeans. Good noble Indians.
- While the Indians certainly contributed to our knowledge of fauna, flora, agriculture, building, hunting, their contributions pale to the contributions of the Jewish people, both in the realm of the sacred knowledge of Torah and individual contributions of Jews in general to medicine, education, arts.
- The Indian world is gone. The Jewish people will live forever.
There is one important commonality. Neither Jews, nor Indians, nor any people's, are indigenous to anywhere in the world, since people are not frogs or plants. People are not indigenous. People conquer or they are conquered. People migrate. Like "native American" who came from Siberia. As Jews we differ because our conquests were Divine mandated and that is our claim to Israel.
Some people get upset because religious arguments offend them. The lowest of these shills have made a career selling these exotic stories of "indigenous Jewry". They never engage in discussion because theirs is not a rational claim. So they pout and scream and hurl obscenities. Too damn bad. Those self-serving arrogant hasbarites who don't like it, can go beat on a tom-tom to mollify their frustration or take some peyote and go on a lonesome vision quest.
Indigenous rights activists have nothing to say to Jews about identity. They know nothing of Torah and thus they are irrelevant to any Jew who believes in Divine claims. The essence of Judaism is the rejection of the primitive and the pagan. Native American culture embraced and cultivated these things. The Am Kadosh has no commonality whatsoever with those who worshiped nature. And it is perverse to make this foolish comparison.
We have Torah, they have totems.
We have Torah, they have totems.
Labels:
"Indigenous Argument" Nonsense
,
Halacha
,
hasbara
,
Torah
Wednesday, July 6, 2016
Guest Post: Nathaniel Feingold - "On Korach"
Guest Post: Nathaniel Feingold's thoughts on Korach. Thank you Nathaniel, for allowing me to feature it here.
Korah belonged to Am Yisrael, which was set apart from the rest of the peoples of the world.
Korah belonged to the tribe of Levi, which was set apart from the rest of the tribes of Yisrael.
Korah belonged to the family of Kehat, which was set apart from the rest of the families of Levi.
But none of this satisfied Korah, the son of Kehat's second son, Yitzhar.
Moshe was the youngest son of Kehat's firstborn son, Amram. He was chosen by God to be leader of the entire people of Yisrael. He was the closest thing Yisrael had to a human king at the time.
Aharon was the firstborn son of Kehat's firstborn son, Amram. He was chosen by God to be the Kohen Gadol, and for his sons and descendents to be Kohanim.
Elitzafan was the middle son of Kehat's youngest son, Uziel. He was appointed Nasi of the families of Kehat.
While Moshe and Aharon were the sons of Kehat's firstborn son, Elitzafan was a son of Kehat's youngest son.
Perhaps one could argue that Korah might have been satisfied not to lead Yisrael or to be Kohen Gadol if he had just been made Nasi of Kehat.
Perhaps it would not have been so unreasonable to Korah that the sons of the firstborn son of Kehat receive the first two offices, but to skip over him for the office of Nesi Kehat? Maybe this contributed to his discontent?
Yet Korah was already a Yisrael, he was already a Levi, he was already a Kehati, all special in their own way, and none of that satisfied him.
What reason is there to think that being Nesi Kehat would have satisfied him? Or being Kohen Gadol? Or even leading the entire nation?
What can possible satisfy someone who already has so much, and is nonetheless ready to rebel and attempt to overthrow the whole system over what he does not have?
Moshe, on the other hand, refused on at least two occasions for he and his descendants to be made "le-goy gadol" at the cost of the destruction of the rest of Am Yisrael.
One has to look very hard and carefully (Divrei HaYamim A' 23:14-17, 26:24-28) even to find out that Moshe's sons went on to make up two of the twenty-four divisions of the Levi'im.
And how easy would it have been for Aharon to assert that, being the firstborn of Amram, he should be leading the nation of Yisrael instead of his younger brother, Moshe?
We see shades of the rebellion of Korah later, in the days of Yarovam ben-Nevat.
While the tribes may have had legitimate gripes about the kingdom under Shelomo and Rehavam, Yarovam used their support as an opportunity to usurp the kingship from David, the priesthood from Aharon, the services from Levi, and the capital and chosen place from Yerushalayim and the Mikdash. And all of Yisrael who followed and supported him and his successors suffered from it.
How "fair" and "equal" of Yarovam to open up the kingship, priesthood, and service of the Levi'im up to any Yisreelite.
Yet it was God Who commanded the Levi'im to be set apart and carry out their services. Who decreed that Aharon and his sons be set apart as Kohanim and Kohanim Gedolim and to carry out their services. Who chose David and his descendents to be the legitimate kings of Yisrael. Who chose Yerushalayim and the Mikdash to place His name and for offerings to be brought.
Moshe did not choose himself to lead Yisrael. Moshe did not choose Aharon to be Kohen Gadol. Moshe did not choose the tribe of Levi. Just as David did not choose himself to be king of Yisrael.
What individual or group can decide what is "more fair" or "more equal" in Yisrael than the God, Who formed Yisrael and decreed these things? Everyone has their mission to carry out.
Korah had a mission to carry out within Am Yisrael, but he was not content to be Korah, and to do what Korah was meant to do for Am Yisrael.
Korah's descendant Shemuel HaNavi, on the other hand, spent his entire life serving HaShem and following His commands.
As Shemuel, the descendant of Korah, said when addressing all of Yisrael when they made Shaul king of Yisrael: "It is HaShem Who made Moshe and Aharon, and Who brought your fathers out of the land of Mitzrayim."
Tuesday, July 5, 2016
Guest Post!- Dr. Moshe Schwartz, "Hasbarite Syndrome Part II: What if they got real jobs?"
The leading expert today on dissecting the mentality of the hasbarite activist is surely Dr. Moshe Schwartz. He was kind enough to submit this follow-up article to "The Judean Hammer Blog":
I decided to write a Part II on the subject of
hasbara and the hasbarite personality, since Part I included a lot of
descriptions, and it’s important to go topic by topic to understand this syndrome. So sit back, grab your favorite beverage, and pontificate on this.
There are those who post and vent on social
media during their spare time with the recognition that they will not change
the world. This is not pessimism, but accepting reality. But many people on social
media, including many career hasbarites, are living out a fantasy. The fantasy
is this: I am the general of an army, or a sort of
Terminator taking out all the enemies.
Reality: They avoid real work and holding down a real
job. Their “work” is primarily attending social
engagements, gathering a crowd to applaud them, and shamelessly shnorrering donations so they don’t have
to worry about providing an income for themselves. Some of these shameless career activists shout out, “be at this protest, or be at this event or you can’t
possibly care about Israel as much as I do!” What a weak self-serving battle
cry!
How about this for a reality check? Many of these people don’t take
care of a family. Most of these loud hasbarites are funded by other people.
Most of these hasbarites are without shame or dignity, as they hustle for the
next opportunity to promote their egos. It easy to give a battle cry out like that
when you have pimped people to fund you.
Those who don’t answer this battle cry, work and take care of their families. Many are active in their
communities in Israel. Many don’t not need a camera or video but do the most
“zionistic” thing possible. They live in Israel and raise families, and fight
the battles which have no glory. Most have real jobs and actually help Jews
silently. Many advocate with dignity and Jewish strength. These
people will never answer the battle cry of “be at this protest or be at this
event or you can’t possibly care about Israel as much as I do!” They actually
have Zionist things to do.
My message to these hasbarites. Talk is really cheap. Back it up by deeds and
not just when there are cameras and police barricades to protect you from real
confrontation. Trust me, the “normal” Israeli Jew that vents and advocates does
their part with dignity.
Maybe the reason these people made being a
Hasbarite their career, is because they could not travel as much with a regular
job? Perhaps their egos need the attention they could not get with a real job?
Maybe if they had to work an honest job even as a hamburger flipper, it would
not satisfy their egos? (Now let me be clear. A hamburger flipper at least has dignity to provide his or her own paycheck.) Maybe they are lazy sloths.
If you
want to speak out against the enemies of Israel by all means do so. If you wish
to travel to go to protests by all means do it. But two things. Have the
dignity to work a real job while you are doing these things, and pay your own
way. Don’t suck up money that can
actually go to needy communities in Israel. You aren’t worth it.
And make sure you advocate from a Jewish
perspective with Jewish strength and dignity, without resorting to using
“multicultural tokens” to please political correctness. Be real people. Be genuine.
Don’t pimp yourselves out and don’t let yourselves be pimped. And if you have
the ability to advocate for Israel make sure you advocate for a Jewish Israel.
Sa
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)